Tomato Pie

Jump to Recipe

Tomato Pie

If you’re searching for a recipe that celebrates summer’s best produce, Tomato Pie stands front and center. This Southern-inspired dish blends the richness of cheese with the sweet acidity of ripe tomatoes, all nestled in a flaky pie crust. Whether you’re new to this classic or hoping to revive a childhood memory, making Tomato Pie is simple and rewarding.

Tomato Pie layers fresh flavors and savory comfort in every forkful. It’s perfect for potlucks, brunches, or as a main on a quiet weekday evening. Let’s break down everything you need to know, from ingredients and prep tips to foolproof techniques for serving and storing your tomato pie.

Why Tomato Pie Belongs on Your Table

Tomato Pie is a versatile dish that bridges the gap between familiar comfort food and more novel creations. You get a crisp crust, succulent tomatoes, and the richness of cheese mingling with a creamy mayo-based filling. Even better, it adapts well to local tomato varieties and different cheeses, making it a home cook’s dream.

Showcasing the Tomato

Tomatoes are the star. Use ripe Roma or heirloom varieties picked at their peak for best flavor and consistency. The pie can help you use up a bumper crop or highlight a handful of perfectly red tomatoes from the local market. Their tangy, sweet juice is balanced by the savory filling, creating a harmonious bite each time.

Savory Happiness for Any Meal

This pie thrives at brunch with a leafy salad, anchors lunch with just a bit of crusty bread, and stands alone at dinner with a glass of sweet tea. Because you can serve Tomato Pie warm or at room temperature, it also makes an easy option for backyard gatherings or picnics.

Essential Ingredients for Tomato Pie

Here’s what you’ll need to create a Tomato Pie that’s both traditional and outstanding. Gather these before you start, and you’ll breeze through prep.

• Pie Crust: One 9-inch crust, either homemade or store-bought. If you’re in a hurry, a quality store-bought crust will work well.
• Roma or Heirloom Tomatoes: About 4-5 medium tomatoes, ripe but still firm. Heirlooms add more complex flavor, but Romas bring a classic bite and less moisture.
• Kosher Salt: For draining the tomatoes and seasoning the filling.
• Freshly Ground Black Pepper: Turns up the savory element.
• Cornmeal (or fine breadcrumbs): Adds a barrier on the crust to keep it from becoming soggy.
• Shredded Mozzarella Cheese: Melts into silky strands.
• Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Adds depth and tang.
• Mayonnaise: Binds the cheese layer and adds creaminess to the filling.
• Fresh Basil Leaves: Sliced or chopped, they bring the garden right into every slice.
• Green Onions: Sliced for bite and zest.
• Fresh Garlic: Minced for earthy warmth.
• A touch of olive oil (optional): For brushed edges or sautéed onions.

Step-by-Step: Making the Perfect Tomato Pie

Let’s break down the process, step by step.

1. Prepare the Tomatoes

Slice the tomatoes about 1/4 inch thick. Lay them out in a single layer on several stacks of paper towels. Sprinkle each slice lightly with kosher salt and let them rest for 30 minutes. This step draws out excess moisture, keeping your pie crust crisp.

Once drained, gently pat the tomato slices dry with more paper towels. If you want even less moisture, flip the tomatoes halfway through salting.

2. Bake the Pie Crust

Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). Roll out your pie crust into a 9-inch plate. Prick the bottom with a fork, then line it with parchment or foil and fill with pie weights or dried beans.

Bake for about 15-20 minutes, until lightly golden. Remove weights and parchment/foil, then return the crust to the oven for another 5 minutes to set the bottom. Sprinkle a thin layer (about 1 tablespoon) of cornmeal or breadcrumbs over the bottom while the crust’s still warm. This soaks up tomato juices as the pie bakes.

3. Mix the Cheese Filling

In a mixing bowl, combine:
– 1 1/2 cups shredded mozzarella
– 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar
– 1/2 cup mayonnaise
– 1/3 cup sliced green onions
– 2 minced garlic cloves
– Freshly ground black pepper to taste
– 1/4 cup chiffonade of fresh basil (reserve a little for garnish)

Mix until the ingredients form a cohesive, spreadable filling.

4. Layer the Pie

To build the pie:
1. Place one-third of the tomato slices evenly in the crust.
2. Spoon and gently spread half the cheese mixture over the tomatoes.
3. Add another layer of tomatoes, followed by the rest of the cheese spread.
4. Finish with the remaining tomatoes, overlapping in a decorative pattern for visual appeal.

If you’d like, sprinkle a bit more basil or cracked pepper on top.

5. Bake

Transfer the pie to the oven and bake at 350°F for 35-45 minutes. The cheeses should melt, bubble, and begin to brown at the edges, while the crust turns golden.

When time’s up, take the pie out of the oven and let it cool on a wire rack for at least 20 minutes before slicing. This rest period allows the filling to set, so each slice is clean and holds its shape.

6. Serve

Cut into wedges with a sharp knife. Tomato Pie tastes superb warm, but it’s also excellent at room temperature hours later. Sprinkle a few fresh basil leaves on top of each slice for added fragrance and color.

Serving Suggestion Table

Tips and Customizations for a Memorable Tomato Pie

Experimenting with tomato pie opens lots of creative doors. Here are several ideas to keep your pie flavorful and your crust crisp.

Picking the Right Tomato

Roma tomatoes’ low water content reduces sogginess. If you use juicier heirlooms or slicing tomatoes, increase draining time or even roast the slices in a low oven for 10 minutes before layering.

Avoiding a Soggy Crust

• Always salt and dry your tomatoes thoroughly.
• Use cornmeal or fine breadcrumbs as a protective “bed” on the pre-baked crust.
• Optionally, brush the crust with a bit of beaten egg before filling to seal out juices.

Personalizing Fillings

• Crispy bacon, caramelized onions, or sautéed mushrooms can sneak into the cheese layer for an extra savory touch.
• For an herby aroma, add fresh oregano or thyme alongside basil.
• Swap out mozzarella for fontina, Gruyère, or a touch of parmesan for greater complexity.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

Having leftovers is never a problem with Tomato Pie. Its flavor deepens overnight, and it reheats nicely.

Storing

• Refrigerator: Cool the pie completely. Cover tightly and refrigerate for up to four days. Stack slices with parchment or paper towel between each to absorb moisture.
• Freezer: Wrap whole or sliced, cooled pie tightly in both plastic wrap and aluminum foil. Freeze up to two months. For best results, thaw in the fridge overnight before reheating.

Reheating

• Oven: Warm slices at 350°F for 10-12 minutes. The crust stays crisp this way.
• Microwave: Heat on high for 30-45 seconds. The crust may soften but the flavors remain.

Troubleshooting: Common Pitfalls and How to Fix Them

Tomato Pie’s simplicity belies the potential for little snags. Here are a few:

• If the pie weeps liquid when cut, next time increase draining time for the tomatoes, sprinkle a little extra cornmeal, or let it cool longer.
• If the crust shrinks while pre-baking, make sure it’s properly chilled before baking and line it generously with weights.
• If the cheese burns before the pie is set, loosely cover with foil halfway through baking.

Beyond the Basics: Seasonal Variations

While summer is tomato pie season, you can adapt the recipe. Use roasted winter tomatoes, add sun-dried slices, or even a touch of smoked cheese for a winter twist. In spring, pair tomatoes with lightly sautéed asparagus tips or thin zucchini slices for a new layer of seasonal flavor.

Tomato Pie isn’t just a recipe—it’s an invitation. Change up the cheese. Showcase the best of your garden. Share a slice or two, hot from the oven, as the setting sun colors your kitchen. Every bite tastes like something worth remembering.