Easy Frog Eye Salad (Old-Fashioned Recipe)

Jump to Recipe

Easy Frog Eye Salad (Old-Fashioned Recipe)

If you’ve never heard of frog eye salad, you’re not alone. Despite its unusual name, it’s a beloved dessert salad—especially at potlucks and holiday tables across the American West and Midwest. This classic chilled dish has found a special place among old-fashioned recipes for its playful texture and blend of sweet, citrusy flavors.

What Is Frog Eye Salad?

Don’t let the name put you off. No amphibians are involved. The “frog eyes” refer to the small acini di pepe pasta used in the salad. These tiny, round pasta pearls become the perfect foundation for a mix of fruits, creamy custard, and fluffy topping. The result? A dessert salad that’s refreshing, sweet, and lightly tangy, with a texture unlike anything else on the menu.

Key Ingredients

Bringing together pantry staples and canned fruit, frog eye salad is easy to assemble. Here’s what goes into the traditional version:

• Acini di pepe pasta – The star of the show. Small, round pasta creates the signature “frog eye” visual and chewy bite.
• Canned pineapple – Both crushed pineapple and pineapple tidbits add juicy, bright flavor.
• Mandarin oranges – Canned mandarins lend soft citrus notes and vibrant color.
• Eggs – Combined with juice and flour to make a silky custard base.
• Granulated sugar – Just enough to sweeten the custard and balance the tartness of the fruit.
• All-purpose flour – Helps thicken the custard and bind the salad.
• Salt – Draws out flavor in the custard and fruit.
• Lemon juice – Cuts richness and brightens the overall taste.
• Whipped topping – Provides a cloud-like creaminess.
• Mini marshmallows (optional) – For pillowy texture and sweetness.
• Shredded coconut (optional) – Adds subtle flavor and chew.

Ingredient Table

Pasta Choice and Substitutions

You might not always find acini di pepe on the shelf. No worries. Similar pasta shapes, like pastina, pearl couscous, or even orzo, work well. Just make sure you pick a small size so you keep the salad light and delicate. Cook the pasta until al dente—don’t overboil, or it’ll lose its round shape.

How To Make Easy Frog Eye Salad

This recipe breaks down into three main steps: cooking the pasta, preparing the custard, and combining all the elements.

Step 1: Prepare the Pasta and Fruit

• Cook 1 cup dry acini di pepe pasta per package instructions. Drain and rinse under cold water to stop the cooking and help the pasta firm up. Set aside.
• Open the cans of crushed pineapple, pineapple tidbits, and mandarin oranges. Drain them well, reserving both pineapple juices.
  • Pro tip: Let the fruit sit in a colander for several minutes to fully drain.

Step 2: Make the Pineapple Custard

• In a medium saucepan, whisk together reserved pineapple juice (usually about 1 ½ cups), 2 eggs, ¾ cup granulated sugar, 2 tablespoons flour, and a pinch of salt.
• Place over medium heat, stirring constantly. Once the mixture thickens and begins to bubble, lower the heat and simmer for 2 minutes while stirring.
• Remove from heat. Stir in 1 tablespoon lemon juice for brightness.
• Transfer the custard to a bowl; let it cool at room temperature, stirring occasionally to prevent a skin from forming.

Step 3: Combine, Chill, and Serve

• In a large mixing bowl, gently fold together the cooled pasta, cooled custard, drained fruits, and any optional shredded coconut.
• Add the thawed whipped topping and fold again until evenly combined.
• Stir in mini marshmallows, if you like extra sweetness and a fun texture.
• Cover and chill the salad for at least 2 hours. The cold melds the flavors and firms up the custard.
• Serve cold. Use a spoon or scoop for easy portioning.

Tips for Success

• Give the pasta plenty of time to cool. Warm pasta will melt the whipped topping and change the salad’s texture.
• If making ahead, wait to add the whipped topping and marshmallows until just before serving. This keeps everything fluffy.
• Use both pineapple tidbits and crushed pineapple for the best range of textures.
• For a fun twist, try adding maraschino cherries or substituting part of the whipped topping with vanilla yogurt.
• The salad firms up as it chills; if you prefer a looser texture, use less pasta.

Flavor Variations and Substitutes

Frog eye salad is perfect for riffing. Try folding in diced apples, sliced bananas, or grapes if you want fresh fruit. Swap coconut for chopped pecans or walnuts for extra crunch and nuttiness. For a lighter salad, use light whipped topping and reduce the sugar slightly. Small pasta alternatives include:

• Pastina (tiny star-shaped pasta)
• Israeli couscous (pearl couscous)
• Orzo (a bit larger, needs careful draining)

When using substitutions, cook carefully. Don’t overcook or the salad will lose its “frog eye” texture.

Storage and Make-Ahead Instructions

This salad holds up well in the fridge and actually gets better after chilling for a few hours. If serving at a party:

• Make-Ahead: Prepare the custard and pasta a day in advance. Store them separately in airtight containers. The next day, assemble with fruit and whipped topping.
• Storage: Store leftovers in a sealed container in the fridge for up to four days. Stir before serving; the salad may loosen as it sits.
• Freezing is not recommended. The texture of the pasta and fruit changes too much after defrosting.

Serving Suggestions

Frog eye salad is a staple at holiday gatherings, summer barbecues, or as a sweet side for family dinners. It travels well for potlucks and is kid-friendly, thanks to its soft texture and sweet flavor. Present it in a large trifle bowl, or divide it into individual cups for a neater serving option.

Garnish with extra mandarin oranges or a dusting of coconut for a pretty finish. If you’re pairing it on a buffet, the salad goes well alongside ham, baked chicken, or roasted turkey.

Nutrition Snapshot

While frog eye salad isn’t a “light” dessert, it brings fruit, eggs, and some useful nutrients to the table.

Values are approximate and will depend on ingredient brands and additions.

Why People Love Frog Eye Salad

The charm of this recipe comes from its blend of nostalgic comfort and quirky character. The acini di pepe makes every bite pop with a soft, satisfying chew. The custard supplies creaminess and tang, and canned citrus brings in sunny flavors. Adding marshmallows or coconut offers a gentle richness, and the whipped topping keeps it all light.

It’s a conversation starter, a crowd-pleaser, and—despite the quirky name—an easy recipe you’ll come back to when a special occasion calls for something sweet, creamy, and just different enough to feel fun.

Frog eye salad isn’t just a quirky side from grandma’s cookbook. It’s a celebration of texture, flavor, and the joy of shared meals. Once you try it, you’ll understand why families keep this old-fashioned recipe at the heart of festive tables year after year.