No-Bake Butterfinger Pie

Jump to Recipe

No-Bake Butterfinger Pie: The Ultimate Indulgent Dessert

If you’re searching for a no-fuss, showstopping dessert that combines creamy textures with irresistible crunch, no-bake Butterfinger pie answers the call. This pie offers a velvet-smooth filling laced with bits of Butterfinger candy, nestled in a chocolate cookie crust. No oven, no complicated steps—just pure peanut butter, chocolate, and butterscotch bliss.

Let’s walk through every layer of this crowd-pleasing dessert—from handpicking the best ingredients to simple prep shortcuts and make-ahead tips. Whether you plan to serve it at a weekend potluck or as a weeknight treat, this comprehensive guide gives you all the info you need for perfect results.

Why No-Bake Butterfinger Pie Belongs in Your Dessert Repertoire

No-bake desserts have a special place in the kitchen. With Butterfinger pie, you enjoy flavor and texture without heating the house or spending hours on prep. Here’s what sets this recipe apart:

• Effortless Execution – The entire pie takes about 15 minutes to assemble. Once chilled, the texture becomes rich but airy, making it easy to slice.
• Year-Round Dessert – No oven needed, so it’s great when temperatures climb. The flavors—peanut butter, cream cheese, chocolate—satisfy cravings any time of year.
• Wow Factor – The crunchy Butterfinger topping against a dark cookie crust is naturally eye-catching. You don’t have to fuss over intricate decoration.
• Adaptability – The structure of the filling and crust makes it a template for creativity. Swap in your own favorite candy bars or try a different crust base.

Ingredients: The Building Blocks of Butterfinger Pie

Quality ingredients yield luscious results—here’s what you’ll need, along with a few related tips for picking the best options. This list serves one standard 9-inch pie pan.

For the Crust:
– 24 Oreo cookies (regular, not double-stuf)
– 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted

For the Filling:
– 8 ounces cream cheese (full-fat, block-style; softened to room temperature)
– 1 cup creamy peanut butter (like JIF or Skippy; avoid natural types)
– 1½ cups powdered sugar (sometimes labeled confectioners’ sugar)
– 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
– 8 ounces frozen whipped topping (Cool Whip), thawed in the refrigerator
– 2 cups chopped Butterfinger candy bars (about 6 full-size bars)

For Garnish:
– ½ cup finely chopped Butterfingers
– Optional: warm chocolate or caramel sauce to drizzle before serving

Ingredient Notes

• Oreo crust: Crushing the cookies with filling included creates the best texture. A food processor speeds things up, but a sturdy zip-top bag and rolling pin do the trick, too.
• Butter: Melting helps bind the crust together and locks in the flavor.
• Cream cheese: Letting your cream cheese soften at room temp ensures a super-smooth filling. Cold cream cheese will clump.
• Peanut butter: The creamy style gives you that classic, silky mouthfeel. Natural peanut butters tend to separate.
• Whipped topping: This boosts the volume and has a stabilizing effect. Homemade whipped cream works if you beat it to stiff peaks, but the pie may not slice as cleanly.

Step-By-Step: Making No-Bake Butterfinger Pie

This recipe shakes up traditional pie routines—you don’t need to blind-bake or master fancy filling techniques, but each step offers chances for customization and flavor tweaks.

Prepare the Crust

• Crush the cookies: Blitz Oreos in a food processor until very fine, or crush them inside a sealed plastic bag with a rolling pin.
• Mix with melted butter: Stir in the melted butter until every crumb looks slightly glossy and feels like wet sand.
• Press into pan: Scoop the mixture into a 9-inch pie pan. Press evenly over the bottom and up the sides, using the bottom of a measuring cup to compact it.
• Chill: Place the crust in the refrigerator for at least 20 minutes. Chilling makes it firmer and prevents sogginess later.

Make the Filling

• Cream the base: In a large bowl, use an electric mixer to beat softened cream cheese until light and smooth.
• Peanut butter and vanilla: Add peanut butter and vanilla extract. Continue mixing until everything looks uniform and satiny.
• Sweeten: Gradually add powdered sugar, mixing at low speed so it’s fully absorbed and lump-free.
• Add whipped topping: With a spatula, fold in the thawed whipped topping. Gentle folding keeps the mixture light.
• Butterfingers: Gently fold in 1½ cups of the chopped Butterfingers, reserving some candy for the topping.

Assemble the Pie

• Fill the crust: Scrape the filling into the chilled crust, smoothing the top with a spatula.
• Decorate: Sprinkle the remaining Butterfingers over the surface for texture and color. If desired, drizzle with chocolate or caramel.
• Chill: Cover loosely with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, or overnight. The filling will set to a sliceable consistency.

Serve

• Slice: Use a sharp, thin knife, wiping between each cut for neat slices.
• Plate: Serve chilled. The contrasting layers hold together beautifully straight from the fridge.

Pro Tips for Perfect No-Bake Butterfinger Pie

A few simple adjustments can take your pie from great to outstanding. Here are some practical ways to refine your technique and customize the dessert to suit every occasion.

• Even Candy Chunks: Use a heavy-duty bag to crush the Butterfingers, aiming for small but not powdery pieces. Alternately, a sharp knife lets you control the texture.
• Alternative Crusts: Swap out Oreos for Nutter Butters, graham crackers, shortbread cookies, or even pretzel crumbs if you want a salty-sweet backdrop.
• Layered Look: For extra flair, gently swirl chocolate or peanut butter sauce into the filling before adding the topping.
• Fruit Garnish: Add bananas or fresh strawberries on top for color and a little tartness. Berries pair well with the pie’s sweetness.
• Allergy Adaptations: Substitute almond butter (if tolerated) for peanut butter, and check candy bar ingredients for any allergens.

Table: Possible Variations

Storing and Freezing for Maximum Freshness

One of the joys of Butterfinger pie is how well it keeps. You can easily make it several days in advance, and it holds its shape for gatherings or last-minute desserts.

Refrigerator Storage

• How to store: Cover leftovers tightly with plastic wrap or use an airtight pie keeper.
• Shelf life: Enjoy within 5 days for peak texture and freshness. The crust stays crisp, and the filling remains smooth.

Freezer Storage

• Wrap properly: For longer storage, wrap the whole pie or individual slices in two layers—plastic wrap first, then foil. This guards against freezer burn.
• Serving from frozen: For neat, clean cuts, slice the pie while still frozen and let pieces thaw for 20–30 minutes at room temperature before eating.
• Make-ahead option: Assemble the pie and freeze without toppings. Decorate after thawing for best appearance.

FAQs: Troubleshooting and Customization

Can I use natural peanut butter?
Avoid it—it separates too much for this filling and can cause a runny pie.

What if I don’t have Cool Whip?
Homemade whipped cream will work. Whip 1 cup of cold heavy cream with ¼ cup powdered sugar to stiff peaks and use as a 1:1 replacement.

How do I crush the Butterfinger bars?
Place in a sturdy bag and smash with a mallet or rolling pin. Don’t overdo it—chunks add character and crunch.

Can I make this gluten-free?
Yes. Use gluten-free chocolate sandwich cookies for the crust and ensure your candy and whipped topping are gluten-free.

Serving Ideas: Taking Pie to the Next Level

Butterfinger pie already shines as a standalone dessert, but you can take it up a notch with small, thoughtful touches.

• Presentation: Serve on a cake stand and add a ring of whipped cream around the outer edge for an extra flourish.
• Personal pies: Use mini tart pans to create individual servings—fun for parties or kids’ celebrations.
• Flavor boosters: Garnish each slice with a drizzle of peanut butter sauce or a few shavings of dark chocolate.

Inspiration for Creative Variations

If you’re craving something a little different, use this recipe as a springboard for other combinations. Try adding a layer of banana slices between crust and filling for “elvis pie” vibes or swirl in raspberry sauce for a peanut butter and jelly twist.

Summary: Why This Pie Is a Keeper

No-bake Butterfinger pie delivers creamy, dreamy filling with bits of candy in every bite, all without an oven. It’s easy to personalize, keeps well, and draws rave reviews from chocolate and peanut butter fans alike. With simple steps and customizable layers, this pie can anchor any dessert table—from holidays to weeknight treats.

Make it your signature, and watch it disappear at every gathering.