Sweet Potato Pie

Velvety, spiced, and wrapped in a golden crust—sweet potato pie brings a touch of comfort to any table. Often found at Thanksgiving spreads or winter gatherings, the classic Southern sweet potato pie boasts timeless appeal. This recipe guides you through every detail, from selecting the best sweet potatoes to mastering a flawless custard filling and learning proper storage for leftovers. The result? A homemade dessert that’s both satisfying and straightforward.

What Makes Sweet Potato Pie Special

Sweet potato pie stands apart through its use of roasted sweet potatoes, real dairy, and a burst of aromatics. The filling is more substantial than pumpkin pie but lightened by whipped eggs and milk. Instead of overwhelming spice, you taste the earthiness of sweet potatoes with gentle hints of cinnamon and nutmeg. The balance between naturally sweet roots and creamy custard creates a dessert that feels nostalgic yet fresh.

Ingredients and Alternatives

Your pie will only be as good as your ingredients. Here’s what goes into a great sweet potato pie, along with ways to swap out or upgrade specific elements.

Ingredient	Purpose in the Pie	Notes & Swaps
Sweet potatoes	Rich, silky base	Use medium to large orange-flesh potatoes
Granulated sugar	Sweetens and balances flavor	Brown sugar for extra depth
Eggs	Sets the custard	Bring to room temperature
Unsalted butter	Adds richness	Salted butter also works, reduce added salt
Whole milk	Creamy texture	Evaporated or half-and-half for denser filling
Vanilla extract	Fragrance and flavor	Pure extract preferred
Cinnamon & nutmeg	Warmth and aroma	Or pumpkin pie spice blend
Pie crust	Flaky vessel	Store-bought or homemade
Salt	Balances sweetness	Just a pinch suffices

Optional Add-ins:
– A dash of ginger spice for warmth
– Maple syrup or honey for a twist
– Lemon zest to brighten the flavor

Preparing Sweet Potatoes

Fresh sweet potatoes give your pie deep flavor and natural sweetness. Roasting brings out their sugars and reduces moisture while boiling serves for speed. Here’s how to prepare them for your filling:

Roasting Method

Preheat the oven to 400°F (200°C).
Scrub three medium sweet potatoes (about 1 3/4 pounds).
Pierce them with a fork and place directly on the oven rack.
Roast until very tender, about 50–60 minutes.
Let them cool, peel, and mash until smooth.

Boiling Method

Peel and cube the sweet potatoes first.
Boil in a pot of water until fork-tender, about 20–25 minutes.
Drain thoroughly and mash to a fine consistency.

Tip: After mashing, run the potatoes through a sieve for the smoothest puree.

Making the Pie Filling

The best filling is velvety, stable, and beautifully spiced. Creating a balanced custard means using the right ratios and technique.

Core Steps

In a large bowl, combine 2 cups mashed, cooled sweet potatoes and 1/2 cup unsalted butter (softened). Beat until very smooth.
Add 1 cup granulated sugar, two large eggs, and 1 teaspoon vanilla extract. Beat until well-blended.
Blend in 1/2 cup whole milk, 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon, 1/4 teaspoon fresh nutmeg, and 1/2 teaspoon salt. Mix until cohesive and creamy.

Example Variation: Swap half the sugar for brown sugar to create a caramel note.

Selecting the Pie Crust

Both homemade and store-bought crusts give excellent results. If you want to make your own:

Combine 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, 1/2 teaspoon salt, and 1/2 cup cold butter. Cut butter into flour until pea-sized pieces form. Add 3–4 tablespoons ice water, mix just until dough comes together. Chill for 1 hour, then roll out and line a 9-inch pie pan.

For store-bought: Use a good-quality, deep-dish, unbaked crust. Allow it to thaw if frozen.

Assembly and Baking

Steps to Assemble

Preheat oven to 350°F (175°C).
Roll out pie crust and press into a 9-inch pan. Flute or crimp the edges for strength and style.
Pour the prepared filling into the raw crust, smoothing the top with a spatula.
Bake on the rack in the lower third of your oven for 50–60 minutes. The center should quiver slightly when moved but not appear liquid.
Remove the pie and cool completely on a wire rack.

Tip: If the crust edges brown too quickly, cover loosely with foil midway through baking.

Jiggle Test Explained

Gently shake the pie pan. The outer edges should appear set, but the center will wobble. It sets further as it cools, so avoid overbaking.

Serving Suggestions

Cool sweet potato pie slices cleanly, retaining their shape. Always let it cool to room temperature for clean cuts and best flavor. Here are ways to serve:

Classic: Plain with a dollop of whipped cream.
Southern style: A sprinkle of toasted pecans.
Indulgent: Caramel drizzle or a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Festive: Toasted marshmallows or candied ginger.

For special presentations, dust lightly with cinnamon before serving.

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips

Sweet potato pie stores well, making it a great dessert for planning ahead. Follow these steps:

In the fridge:
– Cool pie fully.
– Cover tightly with foil or plastic wrap.
– Keep refrigerated for up to 4 days.

In the freezer:
– Wrap cooled pie whole or by the slice in two layers of plastic, then foil.
– Freeze for up to 3 months.
– Thaw overnight in the refrigerator.

Reheating Pie Without Losing Texture

To warm individual slices, microwave on low for 30 seconds at a time until just heated—not hot. For a whole pie, cover loosely and bake in a 300°F oven for 20–30 minutes.

Troubleshooting Common Problems

Issue	Cause	Solution
Runny filling	Undercooked or excess moisture	Use roasted potatoes; bake longer
Cracked surface	Overbaked custard	Remove from oven when center jiggles
Soggy crust	Excess liquid, pie not cooled properly	Drain potatoes; cool before slicing
Overly dense texture	Undermixed or cold butter in filling	Fully blend all ingredients

Tips for Next-Level Pie

Allow eggs and milk to reach room temperature for smooth mixing.
For depth, add a pinch of ground ginger or cardamom.
Brush raw crust with beaten egg just before filling for a golden rim.
Serve with lightly sweetened whipped cream or sour cream for contrast.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is sweet potato pie healthier than pumpkin pie?
Sweet potatoes contain more fiber and vitamin A, but both pies include sugar and crust. The overall calorie content depends on how each dessert is made.

Can I make sweet potato pie dairy-free?
Yes, swap in coconut milk and vegan butter. The filling still comes together well, with coconut adding a mild flavor.

Can I use canned sweet potatoes?
You can, as long as they’re drained and unsweetened. Mash well to eliminate lumps.

How far in advance can I make it?
Prepare up to two days ahead and chill until ready to serve. The crust may soften if you store it longer.

Closing Notes

Sweet potato pie brings warmth and tradition to the table, yet leaves room for creativity every time you bake. Experiment with spices, swap crusts, or try a whipped, marshmallow topping—whatever you choose, enjoy this deeply rooted dessert with those you care about most.

Sweet Potato Pie
Jump to Recipe